Quibbling with Jarvis
Posted by Tim at 02/19/09 12:52 PM

With the President and Congress acting fast, the Defend Your Dollars team has been swinging away on behalf of consumers on everything from credit cards to pre-paid cards to the use of TARP tax dollars. However the last couple of days have been dominated by mortgages.

Now, that the chickens are roosting, everyone wants to look for someone to blame. Of course, the banks--which created these toxic loan products to begin with and then passed the loans on to investors--are to blame. This video explains in simple terms how all the parts of the problem are interconnected, and is well worth the 11 minutes of your time it will take to watch.


The Crisis of Credit Visualized from Jonathan Jarvis on Vimeo.

This piece by Jonathon Jarvis does a fantastic job of drawing a clear picture of the mortgage crisis' origins. After watching, I do want to quibble with one oversimplification (I know, to get the credit crisis down to an 11 minute explanation you have to oversimplify). A "sub-prime borrower" is not equivalent to "an irresponsible borrower." Mortgage brokers pushed home loans on the elderly, the mentally incapacitated, and the desperate. Home equity loans (because of the rising value of houses) became the bank's proffered solution for people already over their heads in debt. Take a moment to look at the videos we've posted here to see the kinds of people who got taken by toxic loans. If we all come to believe that this only happened to irresponsible people, then we as a country will never institute the much needed rules to prevent another crisis just like this one in the future.

By the way, no one should be surprised by the collapse of a mortgage market increasingly predicated on predatory practices. Congress held hearings on predatory loan practices back in 1998--before the worst kinds of loans had even been invented. We congratulated the government then for finding the problems and urged it to get serious about solutions. Boy were we optimistic!

The Huff herself at Huffington Post did a great post on mortgages and hopes to post even more stories from people who got the toxic mortgages that are at the heart of this mess.

The fantastic Sarah Byrnes at AFFIL did a great post on Change.org and reposted it on AFFIL’s new blog about the legislation needed to authorize mortgage "cramdowns"--a process for bankruptcy judges to alter the terms of a home mortgage as part of a bankruptcy proceeding. Today, if you lose your job and face bankruptcy, you can work with your lenders to come up with a repayment plan for most everything except your mortgage. With big banks announcing foreclosure moratoria everywhere, it's clear that just taking your house doesn't even work for the bank anymore.

Finally, some of the comments at Politico were caustic in reaction to Obama’s mortgage plan.

Here is CU's reaction after we read the facts and thought about it for a minute.

Tell us your reaction to Obama's plan in the comment section below.